Not really, since I don’t like yaoi. Or rather, I don’t like the yaoi of fangirlism because I can’t see it. Granted, I usually avoid yaoi and have not read much of it (again, because the idea often strikes me as too ludicrous to really dive into) but seeing a fic’s premise as such often makes me stop and ask myself, “How in the world does that work out? How do you take a guy who acts like that and make him fall for another guy?” My mind conjures images of self-loathing (or even just loathing for the object of his desire as misplaced anger) instead of love and pride; the men I know usually vehemently deny being homosexual and those who are and have accepted that part of themselves only do so after a period of self-doubt, denial, and ultimately pain because of the reality of it. The lucky ones are those who have the support to really live an open life.
I do not doubt in reality that many gay men are macho men; I think I actually saw/read that somewhere. And, hell, anime is rife with bishounen guys who are girly (at least in appearance–perhaps too beautiful for their own good) that are probably loads of fun to slash. But so many of their personalities don’t even hint at tendencies toward being homosexual. In fact some are painfully made out to be ladies’ men and who undoubtedly enjoy women–and so many of these slashed characters are often in worlds that would seem to or would very likely disdain homosexuality. So these manly men just suddenly hit on other manly men… like women. They act like women. Yes! They go lovey-dovey and gushy… like women. These are not the manly men we began with. I’ll let all that romantic stuff go on in the bedroom–that I can understand. But the courting… what are the chances that two manly men are so acceptingly homosexual?
Pull off yaoi correctly and, yeah, I’ll give it to you. I have nothing against it. I mean, hell, I immensely enjoy Jacqueline Carey’s world and the D’angeline “Love as thou wilt” (which, literally, they do, loving whomever and however they want to–but the D’angelines have always been like that and the society is completely accepting of, open to, and encourges it). If you’re going to slash, ok, go for it–but make it realistic. Don’t forget about that angst, that human self-doubt. Don’t forget the MALE EGO!
I’m a romantic sap (hell, my secret vice is yuri–which logically works for me because I can completely see women acting so emotional (or in some cases, not)–hell, groups of women are so close that often that’s just the next step in some cases (though one not often crossed and that’s probably a good thing)). Hell, I think yaoi might actually just be yuri in disguise sometimes how these men act.
But… alas, even though I’ve gotten on my soapbox, I’m not going to write a yaoi story to prove it. Not in a fic anyway… In the end it is as it always is… to each his own.